How we check
Methodology, October 2026
Nobody can buy a place in this catalog, a position in a list, or a fit verdict.
This page says what money can and cannot do here, how a part earns its place, what ✓ Verified claims, how a verdict is made, what we check and what we do not, and what a figure marked estimate means.
You never have to read this to use a builder. It is the one place these facts are written down, so the builder pages can stay out of the way.
What money cannot buy here
Affiliate commissions and manufacturer permissions are meant to pay for this site. Neither is allowed near a result.
- Nothing is ranked higher for a commercial reason. No product moves up a list, a sort, a default order, a search result, a sample build or a featured spot because it has a photograph, because its maker granted us something, because a link earns a commission, or because it is on sale.
- MSRP is the only price basis. Headline prices, saving figures and every ranking that touches money run on the maker’s list price. A sale price, where one is recorded, appears only as a figure labelled Sale and computes nothing.
- No pop-ups, ever. No ad, no newsletter wall, no cookie interstitial, for any reason, under any way of making money. Cards you open yourself are fine. Anything that appears without you asking is banned.
- A maker’s grant buys display and nothing else. Permission to show a maker’s official photographs covers showing them on that maker’s own rows, credited, with a link back. It buys no placement, no ordering, no badge, no verdict.
- The ✓ Verified badge is not for sale. It is set by checking a figure against the maker’s own page, as described below, and by nothing else.
Some parts show links to Amazon, Competitive Cyclist, Jenson USA and Backcountry. The shops are always listed in one fixed alphabetical order by name, never by commission, and every paid link has the words “Paid link” directly under it. A link never changes a fit verdict or the order parts appear in. Detail on the affiliate disclosure page.
How a part earns its place
- A maker sells it. Parts are here because they are useful for planning a build, never because a brand asked or paid to be listed.
- A bike is one somebody actually sold. A complete bike appears only for a product a maker really sold, in the model year the row states. A row invented because a trim level seemed likely is deleted. The one invented bike is a sample build, assembled from real parts and labelled as one. Sample builds are drawn from the parts our catalog can complete, so makers with fewer parts listed here appear less often; that is a catalog coverage effect, not a choice.
- A set is one the maker sells. A groupset, wheelset, brakeset or cockpit set appears as a single card only where a maker sells it that way, with the maker’s own page as the source. A set assembled here is our invention wearing a maker’s name, so those are being retired.
- A wrong row does not stay live. A duplicate, or a row that cannot be corrected from the maker’s page, is retired. A real product with one wrong field is corrected from the maker’s page instead.
- Until a row is verified, it says so. Specs, prices and weights are approximate sample data unless the row carries the ✓ Verified badge.
What ✓ Verified claims
- Interfaces always come from the maker. The maker’s own page or its own document, fetched and read. A search result summary is a lead, never a source, and no retailer or review is a source for an interface.
- Three things travel together. The badge, the link to the source, and the date it was checked. The data checker refuses the badge if the source is not a real address or the date is in the future.
- Weight has one other accepted route. Several makers publish no weights. There a reputable third party’s measured figure for that exact part is accepted, for the weight alone, labelled as measured with its own link. A retailer’s listed weight is refused.
- Figures that drive a rule are never inferred. A frame’s stated tire clearance, a caliper’s stated largest rotor and their kin are recorded only where the figure is published in the maker’s own documents, never read off whatever part a bike happens to ship with. Where two of a maker’s own sources disagree, the more conservative figure stands.
- One narrow exception, always disclosed. A limit a maker does not publish may be stored when three independent retailers state it identically. It is marked as retailer-corroborated, disclosed on the card and in the verdict, and can raise a warning at most, never an error. It is never used where the maker publishes a figure.
- The badge is about the spec, never the fit. Two parts with verified specs can still be a poor idea together for a reason no published figure captures.
- Price is stated on the part. The badge claims interfaces and weight. Whether a price is a confirmed MSRP or an estimate is stated on the part itself, and price never blocks the badge.
How a verdict is made
Every rule compares two things already written down: two named standards, or a figure against a limit its maker published. None of it is a judgement about how a bike will ride. Each builder runs its own rules over its own catalog.
A false “won’t fit” is as bad as a false “fits”, and both are worse than a missing rule. A rule is written only when a maker’s own documents and a test can back it.
When nothing fires, the builder shows a green ✓ No Conflicts. It never says compatible. It means no conflict among the areas listed below, which is not a guarantee the build will work. Beside it, Check Before Building opens the notes for that build, only when you click it. Why? names the rule behind any line.
Findings come in three tiers. Errors mean the parts as sold will not fit together. Where a separately bought part such as an adapter or a shim would bridge the pair, it is still an error, because the checker judges parts as they are sold. A part sold with its own adapter in the box is not flagged. Warnings mean it works but something needs checking, for example a limit published without saying what happens past it. Notes are not a fit problem.
The dot beside a part says the same: green adds no new conflict, yellow adds a warning, red adds an error, grey means there is nothing to compare against yet.
Where a maker publishes no figure, or our data does not hold it, the matching check does not guess. For hookless rims, rotor size, fork travel and tire clearance, the builder counts those checks beside the summary as Not checked with a number. It stays closed until you click it, then lists which fact is missing and for which part. Other checks say so in a note or stay silent. None of these is a pass, and none is a conflict.
What we check and what we don’t
The areas, in plain words. Not every area applies to every bike type. The coverage page lists each rule.
- Frame, wheels and tires: wheel size, axle standard, spoke holes, tire width against frame, fork and rim, bead seat, hookless and tubular rims, tire pressure against the rim maximum.
- Drivetrain: one system, speed counts, shifter and derailleur actuation, cassette range and derailleur capacity, chain and chainring interfaces, crank and bottom bracket, derailleur mounting, freehub driver.
- Brakes: mounting, brake system and lever, fluid, rotor size and thickness against the caliper, rotor to hub interface, rotor size against frame and fork.
- Front end and suspension: steerer, headset, fork travel and length against the frame, rear shock fit.
- Contact points: seatpost and dropper diameter, dropper remotes, handlebar to stem clamp, grips, saddle clamp.
- E-bike systems (the e-MTB builder): motor, battery, display and controller against the frame and crank.
What no builder checks: whether the bike fits your body, how it will ride, torque and the lengths of bolts, hoses, cables, chains and spokes, wear and age, installation and workmanship, race rules, safety approvals and local law, and price, stock and where to buy. These are not a release schedule. A parts-interface checker is the wrong instrument for them.
Figures marked estimate
A price or weight marked estimate (≈ on cards and in the builder, † or the word sample on part pages) is not a maker figure or a measured one. It is shown, marked, never passed off as either. A price marked estimate is one of these, and the part itself says which:
- converted from the maker’s price in another currency, where the maker publishes no US list price
- a split of a price the maker publishes only for a pair or a bundle
- a listing by someone other than the maker, where the maker publishes no price
- a part the maker no longer lists, or one made only for bike makers
A weight marked sample has no maker weight and no measured weight on file. Running totals add estimates with everything else and are labelled as a sample total and an estimated weight.
How to check us
- Follow the source. Every verified row carries the address it was checked against and the date. Open it and read the maker’s own page. The pages under Parts are generated from the same catalog, so each version’s source and check date sit in its details.
- Ask the verdict why. Inside a builder, the Why? control behind any finding names the rule that produced it, the parts it looked at, and where the figures came from.
- Report anything wrong. A wrong verdict matters more here than a missing feature. Where a builder offers a Report a wrong verdict link, that is the fastest route to a rule being looked at, whether one fired wrongly or one you expected stayed silent. Corrections also reach us at the contact address on the About page.